Is It Haram to Use She/Her? A Comprehensive Overview on the Use of Gender Pronouns
Gender pronouns have become a significant part of conversations around identity and respect in recent years. But what happens when this modern practice intersects with religious beliefs?
For Muslims, it’s natural to wonder: is it haram to use she/her or other pronouns?
It may be haram for Muslims to use she/her pronouns if their biological sex is male as it conflicts with the natural order created by Allah. However, Islam encourages respect for all individuals, so using any preferred pronouns when referring to others may be permissible.
Navigating the topic of gender conformity in Islam can bring up important questions about identity and respect. Let’s dive into this complex issue together.
Is It Haram to Use She/Her Pronouns?
To determine if something is haram, Muslims look to the Quran, Hadith (the sayings and actions of the Prophet Muhammad), and interpretations by scholars. Since the concept of gender identity as we understand it today was not a topic of discussion historically and isn’t directly addressed in these ancient Islamic texts, opinions can vary widely.
Some scholars agree that using pronouns that align with a person’s gender identity rather than their biological sex could be misleading or contradictory to the natural order as Allah created it. They might say that since Islam places significant emphasis on truthfulness and the biological differences between men and women, using non-binary or opposite-gender pronouns is problematic.
On the other hand, some may emphasize the Islamic principles of kindness, respect, and protecting human dignity. They might argue that referring to someone with their preferred pronouns is an extension of these values, reflecting the compassion and respect taught by Islam.
Understanding the Use of Gender Pronouns
Gender pronouns like “she/her” or “he/him” are used to refer to someone in a way that aligns with their gender identity. For many people, being addressed by the correct pronouns is a matter of dignity and respect. Using the wrong pronouns, intentionally or unintentionally, can be hurtful and invalidating.
The use of gender pronouns has evolved alongside people’s understanding of gender itself. Traditionally, gender was seen as strictly binary – male or female.
However, as the understanding of gender expanded with non-binary, genderqueer, and other gender identities becoming more recognized, the language has changed which led to the use of a broader range of pronouns.
Islamic Perspective on Gender Conformity
Islam traditionally emphasizes clear gender roles based on biological sex. Men and women have specific roles and responsibilities within the family and society, which are derived from religious texts and centuries of interpretation.
The importance of gender conformity in Islam is often linked to these roles and the natural order. Many Muslims believe that adhering to these roles is essential for maintaining social and moral order as prescribed by Allah.
Arguments Against Using or Referring to Others with Non-Conforming Pronouns
Some Muslims argue against using non-conforming pronouns for several reasons:
- Adherence to Truth: They believe using pronouns that don’t align with biological sex is a form of dishonesty, which Islam discourages.
- Preservation of Traditional Roles: Traditional gender roles are seen as divinely ordained, and using non-conforming pronouns may be viewed as challenging these roles.
- Concern for Social Order: There’s a belief that blurring gender distinctions could lead to moral and social confusion, which they see as harmful to the fabric of society.
These arguments are often rooted in a desire to remain faithful to Islamic teachings as traditionally understood.
How to Respect Others’ Identity While Maintaining Muslim Beliefs?
Balancing respect for others’ identities with personal beliefs can be challenging but not impossible.
Here are some ways to approach this:
- Seek Knowledge: Educate yourself about gender identity and pronouns. Understanding the reasons behind someone’s choice of pronouns can foster empathy and reduce misunderstandings.
- Compassion and Respect: Islam teaches compassion and respect for all. Using someone’s preferred pronouns can be seen as an act of kindness and respect, aligning with these core Islamic values.
- Open Dialogue: Engage in conversations with knowledgeable individuals within your community. Discuss your concerns and seek guidance on how to navigate these situations while staying true to your beliefs.
- Personal Boundaries: It’s important to recognize your boundaries while being respectful. If you find it challenging to use certain pronouns, you can still show respect through your actions and words without directly using pronouns.
Conclusion
Navigating the use of gender pronouns within the framework of Islamic beliefs requires a balance of respect, compassion, and understanding.
While there are varied opinions on whether it’s haram to use pronouns like “she/her” for someone whose biological sex is male, the essence of Islam encourages kindness and respect for all individuals.
By seeking knowledge, fostering open dialogue, and showing compassion, Muslims can respect others’ identities while maintaining their religious values.
